The need and the opportunity to study the economic impact of tsunamis on Spanish coasts
Dr Miguel Llorente Isidro - Geological Risks Area. Geological Survey of Spain (IGME). (m.llorente@igme.es)
Dr Jorge Macías Sánchez - Group for Research into Differential Equations, Numerical Analysis and Applications, University of Malaga. (jmacias@uma.es)
1. Introduction
Figure 1. Database on tsunamis of the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)(2) (https://maps.ngdc.noaa.gov/). The colours show the degree of impact on human lives and the shape of the symbol indicates their cause (earthquakes: a circle, volcanoes: a triangle, landslides: a square).
In Spain (5) it was estimated that for 2017 overnight stays peaked at 40,000 people a day in beach areas in particular. If we take the Lisbon tsunami of 1755 as a benchmark, we can make a rough calculation of the number of potential Spanish victims of an equivalent tsunami to that one which might happen today. In 1755, some 1,214 people perished in Spain (6). At that time the population was 9 to 10 million (7) and given that the rise in the population up to the present day has been close to five times (or even 20 times in coastal zones), an educated guess for the figure would be in the 5,000 to 24,000 person range. In other words, in terms of mortal victims the yardstick magnitude for an event on a par with that in 1755 would potentially and in theory presuppose some 60,000 people taking both tourists and locals into account. In terms of those affected, the figure would have to be far higher. This rough guess should be revised and worked on so as to offer a figure based on more advanced methods and using the most and best-quality data possible.
2. What is a tsunami?
Figure 2. Simplified diagram of a normal wave drawing towards the coast and different zones of the beach according to wave shape. In red, the movement of a particle in the water.
As a wave approaches the coast it rears up on itself, breaks and then advances inland like a sheet of water (Figure 2), although this all depends, besides the characteristics of the wave, on the geometry of the coast, including both the emerged and submerged parts. The fact that the waves lose their shape and break up derives from the inability of the water to remain in a circular pattern when the depth is less than half the wavelength. This happens to the point where the oscillation can be reduced to a straightforward guillotining movement parallel to the bottom. This is why a tsunami is more like a swash or spreading out zone than a proper wave and its march inland keeps to an oscillatory pattern more or less parallel to the terrain (if we ignore the turbulence). When the water’s movement inland dominates, we say that the tsunami is in its run-up, and when its movement out to sea takes over, we say the tsunami is in its backwash. Whereas the run-up is decelerating (against gravity and over a non-flooded surface and thus one with a lot of friction), during the backwash it is accelerating (moving in the same direction as gravity and over a flooded area), so a tsunami in its backwash phase is as hazardous, if not more so, than in run-up mode.
Out at sea and in deep areas, a tsunami has very little height (only a few centimetres) and moves very swiftly, at a speed comparable to a commercial flight (8) (some 900 km/h). Nevertheless, as it draws closer to the coast, due to the effect of not being able to go into an oscillatory movement, the tsunami increasingly gains height. The view of a tsunami from the land is akin to a sudden rise in the sea-level which rushes landwards at the pace of a galloping horse (8) (almost 40 km/h). In short, a tsunami can unleash coastal floods, the destructive power of which originates from both the speed at which the water travels and its volume, as well as the number of times it repeats itself, since it is not in fact a “wave” but rather a “train of waves”, or several in succession. To this we should add that as the flow advances it amasses sediment (rocks, sand) and all manner of objects (cars, waste, tree-trunks and plant detritus) which only add to its capacity to wreak havoc.
3. What triggers tsunamis?
3.1. Tsunamis caused by earthquakes
Figura 3. Relación entre el número de terremotos y su magnitud con un equivalente en energía liberada (en kg de trinitrotolueno o TNT) (10).
Given that depth is perhaps a more critical aspect than the focal mechanism, a distribution map of earthquakes by depth offers an initial insight into those zones which are most likely to produce tsunamis that are triggered by earthquakes and which delineate the contours of tectonic plates quite well. According to the International Seismological Centre’s catalogue, the vast majority of earthquakes happen at a depth of under 50 km (Figure 5) and these are actually capable of generating tsunamis if they are of a substantial size. Nonetheless, most earthquakes closer to the surface are predominantly of the transform mechanism kind. This is why tsunamis of seismic origin are not as frequent as surface earthquakes.
Figure 4.The focal mechanisms of an earthquake (circles with black and white zones) provide a graphic description of the numerical matrix that characterises the relative shifting of two blocks that are separated by a fault (11), which is highlighted by a fine red line for didactic purposes. Indicating the “size” of the tsunami is merely as a guide, other things being equal and without taking into account an earthquake’s secondary effects (such as underwater or coastal slides).
Figure 5. Distribution of the world’s earthquakes where the colour represents the depth of the hypocentre. Modified from the International Seismological Centre (12).
At the international meeting of experts on tsunamigenic sources held at the University of Malaga on 6 and 7 November 2017 (14), three likely zones capable of generating tsunamis with a significant potential impact on Spanish coasts were identified. These are the area of the Gulf of Cadiz in a broad sense (where the earthquake and tsunami in Lisbon in 1755 originated), the Alboran Sea (where there is an abundance of seismic activity) and the northern fringe of Africa (the origin of the first recorded seismogenic tsunami involving economic loss, mainly in the Balearic Islands, in 21 May 2003, which was paid out by the Consorcio de Compensación de Seguros amounting to 350,000 euros) (15).
3.2. Tsunamis caused by landslides
Unlike tsunamis caused by earthquakes, those triggered by landslides affect a smaller area and are thus held to be local tsunamis. This criterion can be used to find out (at least in part) the source of a tsunami when this lies under the sea. Nevertheless, given that we know there is a correlation between earthquakes and landslides in emerged areas, it appears reasonable to think that there might also be a correlation between undersea earthquakes and landslides, so the genesis of many tsunamis could entail an intricate combination of both effects. Other coseismic phenomena, such as soil liquefaction, may also represent triggers of landslides, including those beneath the sea.
It was not actually until the event in Papua New Guinea on 17 July 1998 (an earthquake and a landslide under the sea) when serious thought began to be given to the effect of subsea landslides as a significant cause of tsunamis (21). This tsunami claimed in excess of 2,000 victims. As a result, bathymetric research campaigns were undertaken to provide a better description of the sea floor and deposits from landslides, thereby improving the ability to recognise and map other, similar events since then. In fact, the hypothesis of a major landslide associated with the volcanic side of the island of La Palma in the Canary Islands, where there are records of a multitude of mega-landslides (22), obtained intense media coverage. Yet study of landslides such as these suggests that the frequency of them is of the order of tens of thousands of years and associated with the volcanic processes developing volcanic structures.
In Spain (and in other nearby volcanic regions) the chances of a mega-landslide happening are very slim, so the interest here is more academic than from a planning point of view. At least this is what was concluded at the international meeting of experts in 2017, which was held at the University of Malaga (14). At the meeting it was also concluded that the possible occurrence of smaller landslides close to population centres might actually give rise to locally significant impacts. That said, the slopes of the Italian volcanoes Etna and Stromboli have been the subject of monitoring for decades now, for the double purpose of volcanic surveillance and mega-landslides also linked to tsunamis happening (23).
3.3. Tsunamis caused by volcanic eruptions
In Spain, the Canary Islands are the only volcanically active region, yet to date no study exists which enables any credible relationship to be established (or one at all useful for planning purposes) between the probability of an eruption and the likelihood of this provoking a tsunami; at least beyond the collapse at the sides referred to in the section on landslides (in the case of the island of La Palma). On the other hand, other volcanoes capable of causing tsunamis (albeit where it is debatable whether they could come to affect the Spanish coastline) are Etna, the Azores, Stromboli (which triggered an event of this kind on 30 December 2002 (23)) or others even further away.
3.4. Tsunamis caused by changes of atmospheric pressure
3.5. Tsunamis caused by meteorites
4. Simulating tsunamis
When assessing the impact of a natural hazard, we have to set up certain working hypotheses and here it is particularly useful to link the probability of the trigger factor to the likelihood that the natural hazard will occur. This means disregarding the variability of results due to changes in other variables and so we need to update this kind of study on a continual basis. Given that the amount of different triggers of a natural process, particularly tsunamis, can vary tremendously, any guesswork that focusses on just a single one underestimates the real danger of the phenomenon happening. Despite this, with the data available nowadays, we can estimate quite a lot if we focus the case study on the most likely (or most verified) cause, which, in the case of tsunamis, are earthquakes. Another way to approach a natural hazard is to simulate a known prior event and base ourselves on the premise that “if it has happened in the past, it could do so again in the future”. Strictly speaking, this hypothesis is sound if the processes are cyclical (such as water evaporating and raining down) but for non-cyclical processes (such as landslides or earthquakes) the hypothesis loses validity to the gain of a more probabilistic approach. Even in cases of flooding due to extreme rainfall, although the trigger is a cyclical process, the result (i.e. the flooding) is not, since the morphological changes to the watercourse and the transformation at basin level lead to variation in flooding for identical rainfalls at different times. This is why the validity of this kind of study tends to be limited to the near future, which, for river flooding is a six-year time-frame according to the European Floods Directive (29).
The difficulty in working with earthquakes as triggers of tsunamis, i.e. with the epicentre in a body of water, lies in the fact that their characteristics do not tend to be estimated with the same level of uncertainty as continental earthquakes. This is on account of the distribution of seismographs, the vast majority of which are located onshore for obvious reasons involving maintenance costs, and the fact that a better characterisation can be made of an earthquake with its epicentre on emerged terrain using supplementary studies (geological and even historical ones close to population centres). The lack of marine geology studies that focus on characterising tsunamigenic seismic sources is thus a challenge that should be faced to reduce uncertainty. Meanwhile many of the sources are characterised according to the current state of our expertise, which relies mostly on instrument-based seismic readings and the information gleaned from oceanographical campaigns, which yield bathymetric and geophysical data for such purposes. Such information is used to delineate and characterise the properties of sources and calculations are made of the probability of their rupture in association with their magnitude and the depth of the epicentre.
Figure 6. Effects of the tsunami in Japan (2011).
Source: AFP/GETTY.
4.1. Crustal deformation as a tsunami source
Where of seismic origin, the tsunamigenic source is usually approximated by following the Okada model (30), which bases itself on the theory of elasticity as the cause of the crustal deformation which initially brings about the tsunami.
This model is used to derive the crustal deformation which produces the “initial condition”, i.e. the situation where there is deformation of the free surface of the sea that triggers the tsunami. What remains from this point on is to simulate the evolution of the initial wave, firstly out at sea, and then ultimately to recreate its impact on the coast.
4.2. Simulating the flow of the tsunami out at sea
With respect to the case of channelled water (such as that in a canal) the movement of the water can be simplified by assuming that for a specific section of the watercourse, the flow only follows a single directional vector (one-dimensional simulation). For the case of tsunamis, the approximation can be one-dimensional (in profiles) yet this disregards the effects associated with the interaction of waves as they draw closer towards the coast and due to their geometry, as well as the nested effects of the reflection and diffraction of the waves. This removes all possibilities of evaluating coastal amplification effects, which are critical to explaining many circumstances concerning a tsunami. Despite this, the 1D approach is very well-suited to the study of generalised case studies (or where it proves impossible to pursue any other type of approach) as long as it is followed by first rate specialists inputting reliable findings (32) which can come to be checked against scaled down physical models. Two-dimensional approaches assume that for any point in the calculation domain the water can be displaced in any direction on a plane. The difference between a 1D and a 2D model in computational terms is of several orders of magnitude, both in terms of data demand and calculation time. On a conventional computer, a simulation can take weeks to be completed and, above all, depends on the size and resolution of the calculation domain. Simplification of a 3D model in turn augments the complexity somewhat more and at present is only used for highly detailed cases (in no cases is this on a general or basin scale) and, above all, within an industrial context (turbines, engines, bridge pylons, dams) at an extremely high computational cost.
Scientific literature is crammed with tsunami simulation tests and it has not been until recently that computation has started to slowly and steadily abandon calculation on a Central Processing Unit (CPU) and been performed on a Graphics Processing Unit (GPU), thereby attaining calculation speeds in the region of 100-200 times faster (due to the fact that GPU architecture enables thousands of simple operations to be performed simultaneously, which makes a high degree of parallelisation of certain calculation algorithms).
One of the most advanced simulation models as regards accurate and computationally efficient algorithms has been developed in Spain by the EDANYA group (33) at the University of Malaga. This team of mathematicians has studied and implemented dozens of numerical schemes and compared their results and calculation times until it has selected the optimal code for numerical simulation of tsunamis in the context of Tsunami Early Warning Systems. This is the Tsunami-HySEA simulation model included within the HySEA (34) (Hyperbolic Systems and Efficient Algorithms) family of codes developed in CUDA language for NVIDIA GPUs. The calculating efficiency in resolving propagation has made it possible to cut the calculation times from days (or weeks) of conventional media to only minutes and even (at present) to seconds through using multiple next generation NVIDIA cards (Tesla V100). This is so much the case that this code has been incorporated as a calculation module into the Early Warning Systems in several countries, including Spain, although, for several reasons, there is still a reliance on pre-calculated decision matrices and databases. This system was developed at the University of Malaga and last March received the prestigious NVIDIA Global Impact Award, made for the first time in its history to a non-US research body and it has also passed the standards required by the NTHMP (35).
But for this part of studying tsunamis (propagation), account is only taken of deformation of the floor and its effect on the open sea. On making landfall, the phase of calculating flooding commences.
4.3. Tsunami flooding
When we talk about a flooding simulation, what is actually generated is not in fact a “simulation”. The normal situation is that multiple simulations are carried out such that the errors that can be detected in one particular simulation are ironed out by the next one and so on, until the uncertainties cease to be significant for the purposes of calculation. It is not uncommon for the process to imply dozens of previous tests. As though this were not enough, generally speaking various scenarios are simulated and all the “final” simulations are repeated to check on the stability of the result by applying variations to certain parameters (sensitivity analysis).
The Tsunami-HySEA model uses a strategy of nested structured grids on the same calculation scheme so that the lower resolution (calculation nodes further apart or larger pixels) performs swifter computation and becomes useful in providing contour condition for the next higher resolution grid and so on as appropriate. The same numerical code performs both phases of the simulation: propagation on the open sea and coastal flooding, by adapting the numerical algorithms implemented appropriately in each case. This represents a big advantage when it is used in practice, since it avoids intermediate data processing steps to adapt the propagation model to its flooding counterpart.
4.4. Data required to simulate tsunamis of seismic source
For the case study of Spain, the catalogue of seismic events and the topography is freely provided by the National Geographic Institute and the general public via a website. With respect to active faults the Geological Survey of Spain (IGME) provides open access to the (QAFI, or “Quaternary Active Faults of Iberia”), as well as other sources of information needed to understand the regional tectonic context (the GEODE map — continuous digital geology of Spain and spin-off or associated products). As for the tsunamigenic seismic sources, work is still ongoing to reach agreement on the parameters. Regarding bathymetry, the Geological Survey of Spain belongs to the EMODnet (European Marine Observation and Data Network (36)), which generates continuous bathymetric coverage that is as uniform and consistent as possible using data from an assortment of oceanographic campaigns. The latest available version is from September 2018 and features a pixel of 250x250 metres. We additionally need to have higher resolution bathymetries of the zone close to the coast, which can be obtained from different quarters, such as the Navy Hydrographic Institute, the Ministry of Ecological Transition and oceanographic research projects (such as FAUCES (37), which includes partners of great renown, such as the Geological Survey of Spain, the Institute of Marine Sciences [Spanish National Research Council], the Spanish Oceanographic Institute, the University of Salamanca and the Commission for Marine Geology of the Spanish Geological Society).
Figure 7. Data required to characterise the seismo-tsunamigenic source: epicentre coordinates (latitude, longitude); hypocentre depth (km); net slip in metres; strike direction and dip direction measured in degrees from the north, eastwards; plunge direction; rake; and lastly the length and width of the fault plane (km).
4.5. Results of tsunami simulations
- wave heights in the vicinity of the coast, since these provide a key benchmark for estimating the “intensity” we can expect from a tsunami along a coast;
- the time for the first wave (positive or negative) to arrive or of the most significant wave (represents the maximum available window for any self-protection action and early warning);
- virtual tide gauge records at particular points (where we can observe the full oscillation of the tsunami over time).
With respect to the flooding part, the following variables are typically used (Figure 10):
- the maximum run-up height of the tsunami (which provides information on the limit affected inland in terms of the height above sea level which the tsunami reaches along the coast);
- the maximum water depth at each flooded point (which implicitly includes the maximum extension or reach);
- the top speed of the water at each flooded point (although this is actually less common than the depth because processing is very demanding; to start with it implies two values per pixel: an east-west module and a north-south module, and then the spatial variation of this is very large);
- the specific water flow at each point (which includes the classic concept of the volume of water moved per unit of time at each point, with or without indication of its direction).
Figure 9.Example of virtual tidal gauge reading at two points located before and after a harbour breakwater (39).
Figure 10.Example of three parameters (depth, speed and flow) obtained using the Tsunami-HySEA model and post-processing in a Geographic Information System (39).
5. Assessing the damage caused by a tsunami
It should be pointed out that for the Spanish case study, one should review the validity of this model, in particular as regards its incorporation into the general approach developed by the IGME for the Consorcio de Compensación de Seguros (46) (CCS) for the purposes of quantitative gauging of economic loss. The quantitative interpretation of other, similar publications might be especially useful in this regard, such as the Guide to reducing the vulnerability of buildings against flooding (the “Guía para la reducción de la vulnerabilidad de los edificios frente a las inundaciones”) produced by the CCS (47).
6. Discussion
The first hazard which Europe managed to quantify and visualise by using a mapping tool was flooding, and this was only thanks to the proclamation of the European Floods Directive (29) which became effective in 2007 and subsequent implementation of it under national regulations. Less than a year afterwards, the IGME published a technical handbook on drawing up flood mapping (48), and four years later the then Ministry for Agriculture, Fisheries, Food and the Environment (MAPAMA) published a guide on setting up the National Mapping System for Floodable Zones (49),(50).
All of this was the fruit of a major effort beforehand by various working groups where the IGME and the Directorate General for Civil Protection and Emergencies (DGPCYE) insistently asked for tsunamis to be included as part of the research into coastal flooding risks. Even so, tsunamis were explicitly left out of the European Floods Directive, as well as transposition of it and completely side-lined. The Sumatra tsunami in 2004 and that in Japan in 2011 stoked worldwide interest in events of this kind and concern within the Spanish government about tackling this issue grew.
In 2015 a major step was taken towards studying tsunamis in Spain: the DGPCYE published the relevant Basic Guidelines (51) and two years later, in 2017, the qualitative study of areas of interest was presented (52), which emphasises the Peninsula's Mediterranean coasts, the Gulf of Cadiz, the Canary Islands and the Balearic Islands as priority areas relative to the Galician and Cantabrian coasts for undertaking future efforts.
7. Conclusions
There is no doubt about it: a tsunami will occur that will hit Spanish coasts. This is as much a truism as saying that the sun will rise tomorrow. Nonetheless, we cannot predict when, or how, or which section of the Spanish coastline will be hit by the upcoming tsunami.The maps and studies of risks are not aimed at predicting and in fact the last thing that is intended is for even one of the premises on which they are based to come true. The intention is for risk maps to serve as a means to alert about the potential undesirable consequences so that, right from day one of their publication, or even before via efforts to disseminate, such as this very article, a start is made on providing a remedy to mitigate such effects, where such consequences are calculated using state-of-the-art science available at any time.
Unlike early warning systems, where the aim is to notify using the best possible information, thereby providing those concerned as accurately as can be of what is about to strike, maps and studies of natural hazards make it possible to become aware of a reality that will not just disappear by not taking any notice of it; they enable planning thresholds to be established that are consistent with the technical and budgetary circumstances as well as any suitable measures to be conceived to follow Japan’s example, where the objective (which is somewhat utopian today) is “zero victims from natural disasters” (1).
The perfect setting is in place today to spearhead an initiative to study tsunamis in Spain. It will not be a perfect study (these do not exist) since, among other things, we have to have more detailed geological information on oceans, but while this is on its way, we cannot miss out on that particular wave. The know-how is here in Spain and at the highest level internationally. If we fail to make a start now, tomorrow might prove too late.

Effects of the tsunami in Japan (2011).
Source: AFP/GETTY.
The maps and studies of risks are not aimed at predicting and in fact the last thing that is intended is for even one of the premises on which they are based to come true. The intention is for risk maps to serve as a means to alert about the potential undesirable consequences so that, right from day one of their publication, or even before via efforts to disseminate, such as this very article, a start is made on providing a remedy to mitigate such effects, where such consequences are calculated using state-of-the-art science available at any time.
